The worst Dallas Cowboys team ever?

Plenty of people will sit down, grind through the data, and tell us whether the Dallas Cowboys of 2026 are the worst team ever. All I can tell you is that they’re very bad. They are epically bad.

The offensive line, touted as a strength, has proven to be just okay. They’re not great. They seem to be struggling to pick up the blitz, and they can’t run block to save their lives. (According to Pro Football Focus, the offensive line ranks 11th in run blocking and 20th in pass blocking. To me, that seems about right.)

Everybody’s talked about the defense, and the defense deserves it. The defense’s display against the Arizona Cardinals was deliciously bad. The fact that the Cowboys allowed Gardner Minshew and the Arizona Cardinals, with no No. 1 wide receiver, to score four consecutive touchdowns in the fourth quarter is laughable. Earlier this season, people were talking about how the Dallas Cowboys got the best of the Micah Parsons trade. As we sit back and watch our defense struggle to generate pressure on a second-string quarterback like Gardner Minshew, you have to think Micah Parsons would have helped.

Historical Context: The Worst Defensive Troughs (Last 20 Years)

To understand how modern struggles stack up, it helps to look at the statistical nadirs of the past two decades:

  • The 2025 Collapse (32nd in Points Allowed): Statistically, last season’s defense cratered to historic lows for the franchise, surrendering a staggering 511 total points (30.1 points per game), ranking dead last (32nd) in the NFL. They struggled immensely against the run, giving up 24 rushing touchdowns, and lacked any foundational strength to lean on, triggering a massive defensive overhaul.
  • The 2020 Mike Nolan Era (Historic Yardage & Scoring): Before 2025, the 2020 defense was widely considered the most unwatchable unit in modern Dallas Cowboys history. Plagued by blown coverages and an inability to stop the run early in the year, they gave up 473 points (then a franchise record for a 16-game season) and finished near the bottom of almost every major metric, yielding over 380 yards per game before stabilizing slightly down the stretch. I had high hopes that Mike Nolan would give us the reincarnation of the doomsday defense. That didn’t happen.
  • The 2013 Rob Ryan / Monte Kiffin Transition (32nd in Yards): The 2013 defense gave up a then-franchise record 6,645 total yards (an abysmal 415.3 yards per game), ranking 32nd in the NFL in total defense. The unit was constantly hammered by injuries and a lack of personnel depth.

How Past Lows Compare to Typical Cowboys Baselines

For perspective, a good Dallas Cowboys defense during this 20-year span usually looks very different:

  • The Peak Years (e.g., 2009 & the Dan Quinn Era): In 2009, the defense held opponents to just 15.6 points per game. Under Dan Quinn in the early 2020s, the unit relied heavily on splash plays, high turnover margins, and Micah Parsons’ pass-rush disruption to finish near the top of the league in takeaways, masking other structural flaws.
  • The Middle Ground: Most average-to-mediocre Cowboys defenses over the last 20 years (such as various Jason Garrett-era squads) usually hovered around the 15th to 22nd marks in total yards, occasionally bending heavily in the red zone but avoiding the complete statistical free-falls seen in 2020 and 2025.

Jerry Jones continues to make terrible decisions for the Dallas Cowboys. The personnel on the field just simply aren’t that good. Sooner or later, you have to say the coaches aren’t doing what is necessary to put players in position to make plays. Should Brian Schottenheimer be an NFL head coach? I don’t know. All I can tell you is that he doesn’t seem to be doing the job.

Subscribe for updates!
ABOUT AUTHOR
Errington C. Thompson, MD

Dr. Thompson is a surgeon, scholar, full-time sports fan and part-time political activist. He is active in a number of community projects and initiatives.

Books

A Letter to America

The Thirteeneth Juror

Where is The Outrage Topics
Categories
FOLLOW ME ON