In 2024, a young woman left her dorm room at Cornell University. She had already been drinking, and it’s my understanding that the dorm mother was not supposed to let anyone who was intoxicated leave the dorm. She went out and had drinks at a bar. It turns out she was underage and shouldn’t have been served there. She then left her friends and went to visit a friend at the Chi Phi fraternity house. Upon arriving at the Chi Phi fraternity house, her friend offered her more alcohol. Somehow, she was given ketamine, a known medical hypnotic, and was sexually assaulted for hours by as many as seven men.
The only reason we know about this case is that the young woman, known as Jane Doe, has filed a civil lawsuit against Cornell University and the seven men who allegedly assaulted her.
In my opinion, this case is about failure. There are several guardrails in place to prevent something like this from happening; yet, in violation of Cornell’s rules and regulations, this young woman was allowed to leave her dorm intoxicated. There are state laws preventing underage alcohol consumption, and yet this woman was not carded. Even if you assume she was of age, she was clearly intoxicated and probably should not have been served any more alcohol. She went to the bar with her “friends,” yet they let her walk alone to the Chi Phi fraternity house, even though she’d been drinking all day. This woman went to the Chi Phi fraternity house to see a “friend.” If this was truly a friend, that friend failed her, failed her spectacularly. The Chi Phi fraternity house seemed to have a group Snapchat in which members of the house were invited to have free sex with this inebriated, incapacitated woman.
After her assault, she petitioned Cornell University to drop out of the semester, and she wanted a refund on her tuition. Cornell University refused. Let that sink in for just a minute. Basically, Cornell was telling her that she had to stay in the same environment as her accused rapists for the next several months, pretending that nothing had happened.
The Cornell University Police Department turned over whatever evidence it had obtained to Tompkins County District Attorney Matthew Van Houten. Unfortunately, it does not appear that anyone in the district attorney’s office reviewed all the evidence. Instead, it appears they reviewed a six-page summary that left out many key details. The district attorney decided not to file charges. Now, two years later, he has decided to reopen the case and see whether it has any merit. Again, let me reiterate, this is failure. This poor woman looked to our justice system to get some sort of remedy for this heinous act that was committed against her. It appears the district attorney did not take the time or effort to review all the evidence. This kind of egregious failure should lead to disbarment, don’t you think?
I think this points to a bigger failure of our society: that for years, we have failed women. We have told women that they should not walk alone, that they need to take defense classes, that they should carry mace or pepper spray. We have told them not to dress provocatively. Yet when you think about it, isn’t all of this backward? Shouldn’t we be telling men that we should not assault women? Shouldn’t we tell men that if we see an intoxicated, inebriated female, we shouldn’t think of her as free sex? Instead, we should think about ways to help this woman get home safely. I’m looking at those 50 men in that Snapchat, and not one of them said, “This is wrong. We should stop this. What are we doing?” I understand that sometimes doing the right thing requires some bravery. I’m not sure how brave you have to be to tell your fellow frat brothers that they really should not rape or drug women. That seems pretty basic, doesn’t it?
I hope and pray that this woman gets justice. As most of you know, this case has blown up and is now being discussed all throughout the internet and on social media. Governor Kathy Hochul has gotten involved. She says she has lost confidence in the Tompkins County District Attorney and has appointed Letitia James, the State Attorney General, to investigate. This is the part of the story I find a little ironic, if that is the right word. Now, in New York State, you have a female governor and a female state attorney general. Probably for the first time in the state’s history, a woman doesn’t have to answer to men. Hopefully, this will help her get justice.