Lessons of September 11th

From AmericaBlog:

  • The Constitution only applies when the going gets easy.
  • War is the answer, even when you forget the question.
  • The truth is for sissies.
  • America has never faced an enemy as dangerous and as intent on killing us as King George, the Civil War, World War I, the Germans, the Japanese, a nuclear Soviet Union Al Qaeda.
  • The real September 11 story was badly in need of editing.
  • Just because they say it makes it so.
  • We have always been at war with Oceania.
  • A fool is born every election day.
  • Due process is for the innocent.
  • Patriotism means never having to say you’re sorry.
  • It’s all Sandy Berger’s fault.


All I can say is yep.  That’s exactly what I have learned from the R’s.

9/11 ceremonies

From NYT:

Americans observed a solemn day of remembrance today in memorials around the United States to mark the fifth anniversary of the attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, pausing in New York City and at the two other 9/11 sites for moments of silence, tributes and a recitation of the names of those who were killed.

Although hundreds of miles from one another, the three places where the hijacked airliners were crashed into buildings and a field that day were united today by simultaneous memorials that invoked the memory of lives lost. Family members and friends prayed and wept. They held signs saying “We Will Never Forget.” They read poetry and recounted simple tales recreating the lives of those who were killed.

“I’ve been thinking about what Moira would be doing today if she were here with us,” said police Officer Jim Smith, the husband of Moira Smith, a New York City police officer who was killed. more


9-11 remembered

What can you say about the fifth anniversary of September 11?  What could be adequate?  As a trauma surgeon, when ever there is a disaster, there is almost always a role for a trauma surgeon.  I remember feeling, very helpless.  I remember feeling confused, bewildered, overwhelmed and numb.  I like millions of Americans sat in front of the TV for hours.

Before 9/11, I did know something about Osama bin Laden.  I had read a little bit about the bombings in Africa.  I knew about his fatwa.  I knew that he was serious and determined.  Since 9/11, I’ve tried to become more aware of national events and of politics.  I tried to pay a little bit more attention to our politicians and to what they are saying.  Before the 2004 election, I became very aware of the political atmosphere.  But that is another story.

I have read a lot of information on Al Qaeda and the 9/11 hijackers.  I’ve read the .  I have read former Senator Bob Graham’s book, Intelligence Matters.  I’ve read the Senate committee report on the failures that led up to 9/11.  I’ve seen our government try to suppress information about the failures that led up to 9/11.  I’ve seen politicians distort the information.  I’ve seen them distort the conclusions.  I’ve read about information that has been classified while other politicians state the information should be in the public domain.

Although a ton of questions have been answered, many questions remain.  The 9/11 Commission Report, which concluded that Americans lacked imagination, was just too simple an answer to a very complex question for me to be able to swallow it.  I do not believe that missiles were fired at the Pentagon.  I do not believe that there was a huge conspiracy.  But I do think some information was withheld from the public.  Information more damaging to the Bush administration than the August 6 daily briefing.

I do believe that immediately after 9/11, many promises were made.  Promises of security.  Promises of taking the fight to the enemy.  Promises which over time have morphed into something completely different than the original statement.  Why is Osama bin Laden still walking around, free?  Why hasn’t the leadership of the Taliban been arrested or killed?  Why aren’t we still actively pursuing bin Laden with 10 to 20,000 troops?  Why have our priorities changed?

Five years ago, I would’ve never thought that anyone would’ve tried to politicize this horrific event.  Yet I’ve seen the tragedy of 9/11 politicized in 2002, 2004 and again here in 2006.

Finally, in this week’s Time magazine, there’s an interesting interview with Kristin Breitweiser.  She is one of the 9/11 widows that was so vilified by Ann Coulter.  She was asked by a reporter, will you visit ground zero to memorialize your husband, Ron, on the fifth anniversary of his death?  Her answer was thoughtful and sobering.  She said, “I typically spend the 11th along with my daughter, Caroline.  We usually just go for a walk, either on the beach or in the woods, and take the dog for a swim.  We really don’t talk to anyone on the phone.  We just have a quiet day just for ourselves.”  Maybe that’s what we should do.  Have a quiet day of reflection.